Why Are We Overconfident and Overly Fearful at The Same Time?

Why do we believe so strongly in ourselves, yet simultaneously fear losing so much? A new study suggests that overconfidence and loss aversion may not be independent errors of the human brain. Instead, the two behaviors may have evolved together: confidence projects an image of competence to others, while the fear of loss helps keep the risks of such boldness in check. The result is a system far more complex than mere “rational thinking.”
Why do some people believe they are more capable than they actually are, while at the same time harboring a deep fear of losing what they have already achieved?
At first glance, these two behaviors seem contradictory. Overconfidence encourages us to take action and embrace risk, whereas loss aversion makes us think twice before putting anything on the line. A new study proposes that, from an evolutionary perspective, this combination might actually make sense.
The researchers approached the issue from a different angle: perhaps overconfidence does not exist solely because people deceive themselves. It may also serve as a way to demonstrate our competence to others. An individual who displays great self-assurance may be perceived as more capable, gain access to more opportunities, attain higher status, and succeed in persuading others to trust them. The catch, however, is that this same confidence can also lead to poor decision-making.

To understand how these behaviors might have evolved together, the researchers created a mathematical model that simulated different types of people and the decisions they make. In this model, some individuals were more capable than others, and they had to decide how much risk to take and how much confidence to display.
The researchers then calculated the outcomes for each type of person across a wide range of situations, accounting for both the errors resulting from overconfidence and the advantages of being perceived by others as competent.
The model revealed an interesting possibility: for a truly competent person, the cost of being overconfident may be lower. Even if such an individual slightly overestimates their own abilities, they can still achieve good results.

Conversely, a less competent person may suffer far more when they believe they can accomplish something that actually lies beyond their capabilities. For this reason, displaying a high degree of confidence can serve as a relatively reliable indicator of competence, not necessarily because the individual is attempting to deceive others, but because taking such a risk may be less daunting for someone who is genuinely skilled.
Furthermore, the researchers incorporated "loss aversion", our tendency to perceive a loss as more painful than an equivalent gain is pleasurable, into their model. This behavioral trait acts as a check on overconfidence; an individual might believe in their own abilities and project great self-assurance, yet become significantly more cautious once they realize that something of value could be at stake.
An important nuance is that this caution is not always apparent to others. A person might appear extremely confident leading up to a situation, only to act with much greater care when the moment arrives to put something valuable on the line. According to the study, these two behaviors can coexist: confidence helps project an image of competence, while the fear of loss helps to mitigate some of the risks associated with that confidence.

The authors conclude that overconfidence and loss aversion may not simply be two “errors” that should be eliminated. They may have evolved together because, in certain situations, the combination of the two was more advantageous than the absence of both.
This does not mean that being overconfident is always good, or that we should ignore irrational decisions. The point is that some behaviors, which might appear to be flaws when analyzed in isolation, may actually serve a function when we consider how they interact with other people and the environment.
READ MORE:
Talking the Talk, Not Walking the Walk: The Coevolution of Overconfidence and Loss Aversion
Chris Dawson and David de Meza
Psychological Review
DOI:10.1037/rev0000644
Abstract:
A puzzle for evolutionary theory is the existence of two seemingly offsetting behavioral “biases,” overconfidence and loss aversion. Overconfidence is a call to action, while loss aversion curbs initiative. The most prominent evolutionary explanation of overconfidence, proposed by Trivers (1976), is that self-deceit arises to better deceive others. Missing from this account is why sincere messages are believed, especially given the widespread prevalence of self-deception. Moreover, if overconfidence is adaptive, why is it at least partially canceled by loss aversion? We propose a signaling theory according to which the role of self-deception is to better inform others. Since the decision error associated with high self-belief is less burdensome for the more able, and the benefit of being perceived as able increases with ability, hardwired overconfidence is a credible signal of true ability. Evidence supports this interpretation. A further implication of signaling is that loss aversion is part of the equilibrium. It partially ameliorates the decision costs of overconfidence, but as it is usually hidden, it does not eliminate its signaling role. “Biases” are thus symbiotic—the payoff to agents from an integrated set of biases is higher than would be the case in their absence. From this perspective, Kahneman’s advice that individuals eliminate both overconfidence and loss aversion is poorly founded.



Comments